People
are effected by social injustices every day. There have always been
controversies and disputes and the main reason for them are the social
injustices that people face every day. There are unlimited examples of social
injustices but one the main and most common ones are the gender and race gap. The
race and gender gap social injustice has existed for many decades. Race and
gender have always been a controversial issue and will continue to be
throughout time. No one is truly going to be satisfied or happy. Currently, the
gender and race gap is mostly talked about when people mention their salaries
because money is a huge part of the world we live in today. It is what keeps
our country functioning. Although some are satisfied with their salaries, others
are not and feel they deserve higher wages. Some feel their salary isn’t as
high as others because their education isn’t at the same level as others even
if they’re doing the same work or simply because of their race. People have
complained for years that they feel they deserve better pay and feel that
sometimes they have no control over it because they feel like the system is
bias. A question that is asked all the time and should be answered is, does a
person’s race and or gender truly have an impact on their salary? To answer
this question past and current statistics were reviewed. Databases were used to find information as
well. Some say no matter what men make more than women and whites make more than
blacks, Hispanics or any other race. Researchers even take their knowledge and
apply it to the future and estimate if these statements would be true later on.
This social injustice is one of the major ones and many would like to know if
this social injustice, if and why men and whites make more than women and other
races, to be true.
There is an injustice because in every price range men
outnumbered women. One online news article looked at was As Salary Grows, So
Does a Gender Gap. It explains how a pattern was found by David Cay Boyle Johnston, who is 65 years old. He is an
American investigative journalist and author, a specialist in economics and tax
issues, and winner of the 2001 Pulitzer Prize for Beat Reporting. In the
article it’s stated that “the ratio was 10 to 1 in the $500,000
to $1 million category, according to the I.R.S. In the $200,000 to $500,000
category, men outnumbered women 9 to 1. In the $100,000 to $200,000 category it
was 5 to 1. In the $75,000 to $100,000 category it was 3 to 1 and in the
$50,000 to $75,000 category it was 2 to 1” (Johnston, 2002, pg. 8). The gap in
total narrows as pay decreases. Despite all of the different price ranges men
still outnumbered women. However, according to Johnson (2002) “At wages of less
than $25,000, women outnumbered men, accounting for 57.6% of the wage earnings
in that category” (pg. 8). The less money the more women outnumber men and if
the salary is higher men are in favor. Johnston also states that “Economists
say the 1998 salaries were shaped largely from trends that existed a generation
ago, when women were less likely to work outside the home or pursue high-paying
careers” (2002, pg. 9). The reasons for this is because people still have these
beliefs, they are used to women working in the house, and some feel women are still
inferior to men. In mostly all occupations this is true especially in the
education system.
Robert
K. Toutkoushian is currently is an associate professor in the department of
educational leadership and policy studies at Indiana University. He conducts
research on a wide range of issues pertaining to K-12 and higher education.
Before he was responsible for planning, conducting, and reporting studies
related to all aspects of the University System of New Hampshire, providing
leadership in identifying relevant higher education issues to study, and
participating in the planning and policy-related agenda for the Board of Trustees.
Past research has shown that women faculty earn less than men but there is
little data available for minority teachers because there are fewer, and that
single men earn less than married men. The researchers used data from the U.S.
National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) for information on teachers' social
and economic conditions and it was found that there are regional disparities in
earnings by teachers and that factors like length of the appointment, whether
the faculty member was chair of a committee, and what discipline that person
teaches also effected their salary. According to Toutkoushian
(2007) “Results
from empirical studies have consistently shown a substantial unexplained wage
gap in favor of men in both the general labor market and in academia” (pg.
572). The gap isn’t just in academic occupations but in labor occupations as
well. There’s a variety of gaps. Something needs to be done about this
injustice. To fix this issue the main characteristic that should be looked at
is their knowledge of the field a person is a part of and how well they are at
the occupation they are a part of. People should be paid based of what they
know, how well they know it, and how capable they are of demonstrating their
use of their knowledge.
There
are several reasons why people feel this injustice exists. Some point to
current issues or what they feel can be considered obvious reasons. However, despite
everything “others point to cultural ideologies and beliefs about the
appropriate roles of men and women as accounting for at least part of the
unexplained wage gap” (pg. 572). Some people just have a belief that women
should be paid less than men. Whether they have the same education or work
skills or not, some people just feel culturally they should be paid less. Data from the Connecticut Department of Higher Education
and the National Association of Colleges and Employers were used to explore
differences of race and gender in estimated starting salaries of 2006 bachelor
degree recipients from Connecticut colleges and universities. According to Free
(2007)
For females, they had a high presence in majors with low
average starting salaries and low presence in majors with high average starting
salaries. Racial distributions for men showed that average starting salaries
for Whites, American Indians, and Asians will be higher than those for Blacks
and Hispanics. For women, increasing graduation rates of non-Whites should
significantly reduce racial earnings inequality because White and American Indian
women are predicted to have lower average starting salaries than Blacks,
Hispanics, and Asians.
Women are getting paid more in some occupations but those occupations are
the ones that are considered worse than other jobs for many reasons. In
college, women are tending to declare majors in college where the occupation is
a low paying salary occupation. For a while it’s been that Whites make more
than other races and it’s believe that this will continue to be true over the
course of time. With all this being said however, with females, whites are
estimate to have lower salaries than the other races. Not only do men make more
than women but it’s the opposite when it comes to race. White males make more
than other races and white females make less than other races. The reasons for
this are still unclear but in time, with more research and knowledge, this interesting
statistic may have an answer to it.
This social
injustice is an injustice in mostly all occupations not just in the educational
system. The article Characteristics of Minimum Wage Workers (2012) looks at
employment in the U.S. as of 2012. It focuses on workers who earn the minimum
wage or less and provides figures on the share of workers earning the minimum
wage or below who are under age 25. Some believe that race and ethnicity is
more of an issue in this social injustice than gender is. Looking at location
is another good way to get an understanding of this social injustice to see if
that has an affect besides race, ethnicity, and gender as well. According to
the United States Department of Labor (2012) “In 2012, 75.3
million workers in the United States age 16 and over were paid at hourly rates,
representing 59.0 percent of all wage and salary workers. Among those paid by the hour, 1.6 million
earned exactly the prevailing federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour. About 2.0
million had wages below the federal minimum. Together, these 3.6 million
workers with wages at or below the federal minimum made up 4.7 percent of all
hourly paid workers” (pg. 1). The website also states that
About
5 percent of White, Black, and Hispanic or Latino hourly paid workers earned
the federal minimum wage or less. Among Asian workers paid at hourly rates,
about 3 percent earned the minimum wage or less. Among hourly paid workers
age 16 and over, about 10 percent of those who had less than a high school
diploma earned the federal minimum wage or less, compared with about 4 percent
of those who had a high school diploma (with no college) and about 2 percent of
college graduates.
There are so many factors
that come into effect when determining someone’s salary. It should be noted
that some states have minimum wage laws establishing standards that exceed the
federal minimum wage. However, people are getting tired of being dissatisfied
with their pay. Salaries need to be based off of hard work and skill not
necessarily all f these little factors that come into play now.
Along with the website
article, a book was reviewed to possibly help with this question of location
playing a factor as well. In this book it was reported that there has been a
loss of more than 250,000 permanently affordable residential units. Goetz shows
a critical analysis of the nationwide effort to fix public housing by focusing
on the impact of policy changes in Atlanta, Chicago, and New Orleans. He
explains how race has a major influence especially in American cities. African
Americans have been affected by this policy shift where public housing is most
closely identified with minorities that have been most aggressive in removing
units. This proves that location does play a factor as well. In most cases
whites live in nicer neighborhoods and nicer houses than other races such as
blacks, Hispanics, etc.
The gender and
race gap is a social injustice that will be continued to be talked about for
the rest of time. It has been a social injustice for what feels like forever. With
money being such an important factor in everyone’s everyday life, the economy
and salaries are becoming a major issue. More and more people are beginning to
feel that they aren’t getting paid as much as they should be whether it’s
because they feel they are putting in more work that what they’re getting paid
or others are making more money when they possibly shouldn’t be. Race and
gender has will forever be a social injustice controversial issue. People are
going to find new things to complain about and still even if changes are made
people still won’t be happy and expect more. On the flip side, if changes are
made it will help one race or gender but then hurt the others which will cause
another controversy because those that the change is going to be against will
be unsatisfied. There will never be a middle or a case where both sides of this
social injustice will both be happy. For this reason the race and gender gap will
forever be a social injustice, and it may be a social injustice that can never be
fixed.